considering it's mentioned i think that Abby did have Pierre's hair at one point, I'm still a believer that it's Caroline that's the wizard's daughter, and Abby's his granddaughter. That's why when she dyed her hair, the small bit of magic is keeping it at that colour. just my theory tho, and it feels more fitting than thinking Caroline cheated. as for the greenhouse thing, i mean, it's a hobby. everyone needs a chance to decompress and let their minds wander tbh (something irl people have kinda forgotten to do) not saying the towns perfect; lord knows it's got a lotta flaws, but the marriage i don't think is one of them. i think it's a mix of pierre being stressed from joja, the hair thing, the fact that abby's hobbys are a lot different than what he and caroline grew up with (going by the graveyard scene, it really sounds like a lot of her behaviours were probably extremely taboo in their youth possibly). but of course, unless ConcernedApe proves or disproves anything, all we can do is speculate
What a disgusting POS woman wow. I'm a new player and thought all the villagers are cute and its all gonna be rainbows and sunshine at first.. I sure hope he divorces her and disowns Abigail
I think Abigail might know too cause she does go out to the wizards tower or at least the area of it sometimes and says she doesn't remember dying her hair/might know it's natural… Thoughts???
ANOTHER THEORY: We know the wizard was married to the witch for a bit before they broke up but… WITCHES HAVE GREEN HAIR AND CAROLINE HAS GREEN HAIR AS WELL!!
Personally I like to think it's that the Wizard had an affair with the traveling cart lady and that resulted in Caroline, they're the only two with green hair in the the whole game, and I feel like Caroline was drawn there because she could unconsciously feel the presence of her parents in that area. This would instead make Abigail the wizard's granddaughter rather than his daughter which I feel makes more since because Abigail doesn't seem to have too much magic but if we consider Caroline's tea room cutscene, she seems to have magic. I also think Emily is his daughter too and her parents didn't figure out until after Hailey was born and eventually her dad couldn't take dealing with a child from an affair anymore and forced their mom to leave the valley with him and never return.
I honestly hope that Abigail moves to chocolate belly and the wizard moves the chocolate valley and they find out their related to each other. That would be amazing
Abigail's hair color doesn't matter because Caroline said she wishes she would stop dying it that it's naturally a light chestnut. I think it's Jaz. Marnie is a bit promiscuous and next door to the wizard but I don't know why she would warn you to stay away from the tower.
44 Comments
YOU DON'T HAVE THE RIGHT TO RUIN WHAT COULD'VE BEEN MY NEW PARENTAL FIGURES 😭
🤯
Also abigail eats minerals and flowers which can only be explained by witchcraft and magic. 😂
Also purple hair, dead give away
Pierre should just leave her for us ngl, we can be better for him ong
Oi, this shit again.
considering it's mentioned i think that Abby did have Pierre's hair at one point, I'm still a believer that it's Caroline that's the wizard's daughter, and Abby's his granddaughter. That's why when she dyed her hair, the small bit of magic is keeping it at that colour.
just my theory tho, and it feels more fitting than thinking Caroline cheated.
as for the greenhouse thing, i mean, it's a hobby. everyone needs a chance to decompress and let their minds wander tbh (something irl people have kinda forgotten to do)
not saying the towns perfect; lord knows it's got a lotta flaws, but the marriage i don't think is one of them. i think it's a mix of pierre being stressed from joja, the hair thing, the fact that abby's hobbys are a lot different than what he and caroline grew up with (going by the graveyard scene, it really sounds like a lot of her behaviours were probably extremely taboo in their youth possibly).
but of course, unless ConcernedApe proves or disproves anything, all we can do is speculate
average sv player
Help why have I never gotten the Caroline cutscene ??? We have full hearts and I’m not sure she ever gave me tea tree seeds
What a disgusting POS woman wow. I'm a new player and thought all the villagers are cute and its all gonna be rainbows and sunshine at first.. I sure hope he divorces her and disowns Abigail
nah mate Caroline is the wizards and the wiitches daughter and Pierre is just a dumb ass who thinks his wife is cheating when she did nothing wrong.
and thats why abigail eats rocks
Thats probably why she eats rocks..
Makes sense why she eats amethysts
Poor pierre
I thought this was gonna be about the mayor and Marnie's relationship
Not to mention that Abigail eats quartz.
It’s not “jealousy issues” if you’re right about your spouse cheating
I really want the drama to be more confrontational though. Like…murder😮
Thanks, you fricking ruined the game for me.
What the hell I thought this was a farming game not a jersy shorts but… Love it
The witch is Caroline using the magic tea
I think Abigail might know too cause she does go out to the wizards tower or at least the area of it sometimes and says she doesn't remember dying her hair/might know it's natural… Thoughts???
ANOTHER THEORY: We know the wizard was married to the witch for a bit before they broke up but… WITCHES HAVE GREEN HAIR AND CAROLINE HAS GREEN HAIR AS WELL!!
It makes the mod where you can marry the Wizard more interesting given this lore.
Personally I like to think it's that the Wizard had an affair with the traveling cart lady and that resulted in Caroline, they're the only two with green hair in the the whole game, and I feel like Caroline was drawn there because she could unconsciously feel the presence of her parents in that area. This would instead make Abigail the wizard's granddaughter rather than his daughter which I feel makes more since because Abigail doesn't seem to have too much magic but if we consider Caroline's tea room cutscene, she seems to have magic. I also think Emily is his daughter too and her parents didn't figure out until after Hailey was born and eventually her dad couldn't take dealing with a child from an affair anymore and forced their mom to leave the valley with him and never return.
I honestly hope that Abigail moves to chocolate belly and the wizard moves the chocolate valley and they find out their related to each other. That would be amazing
Oh look…the consequences of my actions, must just be my husband's jealousy issues tho.
The wizard is both Abigail and Sébastien's father
abigail also hangs out at the wizards tower quite a bunch
There is an event where you actually see this
Abigail's hair color doesn't matter because Caroline said she wishes she would stop dying it that it's naturally a light chestnut. I think it's Jaz. Marnie is a bit promiscuous and next door to the wizard but I don't know why she would warn you to stay away from the tower.
Don't forget Abby, admitt she hasn't redyed her hair in a very long time. Meaning the purple has stayed ever since.
Thank you for making these videos so I can just farm and not feel like I’m missing out on the lore😂
Abigail's hair is dyed and Caroline is just stressed because her husband is a greedy asshole
Am I the only one that thinks Abigail looks like Pierre?
I mean it’s kinda obvious. She has purple hair, the wizard has purple hair.
So fucked up
Didn't abigail's grandma have purple hair if that's why you think she is his daughter
He is the Rizzard
dang
It doesn't make sense because Abigail naturally has chestnut hair (as said in Caroline's dailouge)
He cheated on the witch with Caroline that's the mistake and why his wife left him
Isn't there a cutscene that literally explains that Abigail is not Pierre's daughter?