Do All Stardew Valley YouTubers Think the Same?

Really gotta just mention here that Cattails has a much richer development history than just being "like Stardew". It's essentially a spiritual successor to Warrior Cats: Untold Tales, of which the first version released in 2011! I'm sorry for the kind of off-topic comment, I'm just really proud of how the little game I played for hours as a kid has lead to something much bigger and more complete.
Also every game should have farming or gardening in it. Lemme in that dirt.

As a nonbinary person, I'd like to play as a nonbinary person without having to override both gender options with a mod (taking away choices instead of adding another option). If ConcernedApe plans on adding another gender option eventually (which I doubt), then great! If not, I'll still play it—the lack of gender neutral options on its own doesn't turn me off of a game—but I might try going to other games to feel represented. I really want to get Coral Island working on my computer and I might consider playing Haunted Chocolatier if there's nonbinary options (despite not being as interested in the combat elements).

I love that he start's off with "Don't worry, none of these questions can make you look bad" and the very first question is "does this person deserve a house" lol

I struggle with fishing so much that some of the content is locked for me…I play on Switch so it’s really frustrating to fish. I’m on Year 6 and haven’t finished the CC or gotten to the bottom of Skull Cavern, or gotten four candles.

Something I'd love to see in Stardew's future is just a lot more achievements, especially like funny or niche ones. Like an achievement for increasing bad gifts, say give out 100 hated gifts and get a little devil horns hat or something like that. Maybe even achievements for length, like reach farm year 50 and get a wearable grey beard

The fact that Little witch in the woods was shown while Seanie was talking about uninspired Stardew rip-offs made me GASP
MY DUDE
DO YOU EVEN HAVE EYES
The audacity

I still haven't seen one person marry linus 😮‍💨

Seaniedew is so correct I typically can't decide to do that I spend majority of year one seemingly dying nothing

Personally I find it hard to agree to any "there is too much of X game on the market" (excluding scams/ asset flips of course) discourse. As by saying yes, I feel you are innately judging a games to be less than simply for deciding to go to the wrong niche. Sure many of them are probably not worth peoples time, but you can't get any diamonds in the rough if you try to get rid of all the rough.

I played starde and almost never watched wiki. Yes ur slower, but the game is so good that u will find what u want anyway

Skyrim is an 11 year old game with millions of people who play and hundreds of mods with high numbers still being released every day

I actually agree with Seanie in that Stardew is not relaxing for new players. I've tried to get unto the game but when i realized there were time limits for specific events that needed to get done i found myself stressed beyond relief. everyone seemed to make it seem like there was no goal and i could go at my own pace like animal crossing but then i found out there's specific goals that need to be met by specific times and i just cant deal with time limits, especially when i didn't know the ropes of the game at all…. (tbh idk if this changed or if maybe the wiki was wrong about this but I just know it made the game less fun and turned me away from it because the impression i was given was wildly different than what i got when playing the game.)

2:40 nuh uh, EXTREMELY disagree, I would destroy the wall on the left side to go beyond the line. One word: TIME. Here's the thing, unlike Terraria where you can just goof around till one month and then proceed to do another boss, you can't do that in Stardew Valley. You have schedules, events, limited time 6AM to 2AM, Granpa's evaluation, crops, animal happiness, villager events and happiness, ETC.

Might be unhinged, but I do still think that Terraria is the most relaxing game ever because there's almost no time constraints. There's few like fishing quest, boss battle time limit, herb farm, night and day events, and etc.

Stardew Valley is an epitome of "WORK" game, you cannot even chill for one second. After you get up at 6AM, you go check TV, check your farm, water, check cave, harvest, water, check your animals, feed, pet, pet cat, fill bowl, talk to villager, give gifts, check board, check forages, check your equipments, and then DO something else (mining, fishing, etc) ALMOST EVERYDAY (except winter).

seanie is the main character

"Four words. One-Hundred(1) Days(2) In(3) Stardew(4) Valley(5)."

Hmmmmmmmm…. seems about right.

Watching this again after Seanie's pumpkin-cranberry battle with Sal and looking for the lack of Seanie's moustache in far away shots is insane. Something I wouldn't have noticed had Sal not admitted to it. Amazing video.

Pam totally deserves the house upgrade. She's fine when you talk to her, has a job as a bus driver and don't forget that the trailer only has ONE bedroom which she gives to her daughter while she sleeps on the couch.

Stardew valley is not relaxing when you get to endgame. The skull cavern is not relaxing at all so i slightly disagree. It really depends on the person if it's relaxing.

Unique content, I don't think it's running out, you just need to get more creative.