The Pale Garden should have been a cave biome

It’s probably far too late for this feedback to be useful but I wanna give it anyways

The Pale Garden would have been perfect as a cave biome. To me the overworld is split into two halves, the semi realistic surface and the hostile and mysterious

In the past Mojang would use the caves as a perfect area for more fantastical and experimental features, such as the deep dark and Trial Chambers

Minecraft’s underground has always been this mysterious place where any fantasy feature would fit right in, I believe the Pale Garden would’ve been a perfect addition to the caves as a rare biome like the ancient city

The Pale Garden feels genuinely out of place on the service and messes with the above grounds vibe imo. Something about the pale garden being a surface biome just feels way off, and not in a creepy way, it’s just wrong imo

Being underground would elevate a feeling of isolation and give the biome a real alien vibe, in some situations you could really be trapped in the biome

While unlikely to happen this change is far from impossible, all the existing pale garden content could just be moved underground

I see Mojang’s vision for the biome, the creaking is an amazing idea, but personally I just really think it’d be even better as a cave monster

Pre-MC Live Pale Garden concept art by @DotJpex