Which bachelorette did you pick? and who do you recommend?
I want to start a new save, and i’m honestly torn. I want to go with either Maru or Emily, I love them both. I’m also considering going with one I haven’t gone with before, Abigail. Who did you pick, and why?
I think people sleep on Penny honestly, she’s adorable, she’s kind, she’s a little nervous but that comes from living with Pam
MarionberryFlaky7444 on
I always choose Abigail because she is adventurous, likes video games and music, goth and has a guinea pig. But another good reason is so you can take her away from pierre because fuck pierre but the decision is 100% up to you I’m just saying my opinion
19Thanatos83 on
Which bachelorette did you pick ? And why is it Emily? (Or penny, *sigh* or Leah)
Honestly all of the “grown up” Bachelorettes are fine.
WarAgile9519 on
I usually find myself torn between Abagail and Haley , although in my latest game I’ve found myself really warming up to Penny.
ScarlettWaffles on
All of them are quite good, having gone through all of them across many playthroughs my personal recommendations would be this:
1. Abigail, she’s got the goth asthetic and independence you have to admire.
2. Penny, honestly just rather wholesome and sweet. Also her bringing the kids to the farm for lessons after marriage just makes the place feel a lil more lively.
3. Maru, nerd girl who grows close to you because you let her nerd out.
4. Haley, annoying at first but is nice to watch her break out of her shell.
5. Emily, she’s quirky and fun. Mostly however I just personally enjoy being a menace to clint.
6. Leah, just because I have her last doesn’t mean her line still isn’t good. Becoming the inspiration for her art is charming, I just personally found hers the least interesting. You do get to punch someone in the face though which earns bonus points.
Of course my ultimate recommendation is to do multiple playthroughs and experience all the story lines. Each one is worth experiencing at least once. These are obviously based on personal tastes and everyone will have different preferences.
Graysvandir on
Abby. She’s not afraid to have and voice her opinion, she’s adventurous, she’s small and fierce, does not take crap from others… Oh, and she has some really funny lines, especially the one during Flower Dance. The fact I completely dig her aesthetics is just a bonus, really.
Livid-Web5252 on
I love Haley and Penny. Haley because I love seeing the character development and Penny because she’s sweet and I want her away from Pam.
Veshmeshok_Camper24 on
I chose Maru in my play through, but I haven’t played in a while and I’m pretty sure updates added stuff to marriage/ relationships (correct me if I’m wrong though). I chose her because I found her interests endearing and I just liked her personality overall. I think Leah is awesome too, I’ll probably romance her if I start another play through.
HanyaPunxNotDead on
Maru. She is underrated, and really sweet. Love my nerdy wife. 
MumIsYum on
I’d go with Leah. She’s the closest you can to Robin without, you know… marrying Robin.
Lifewasoutoflemons on
my first play I picked Maru and she was really great. She makes you food and gives you bombs. My second play I chose Abigail and she was great. I ended up buying her picture and hanging it on the wall. Now I’m married to Haley and I was very surprised at how sweet she ends up being. I kinda hate her room but I love her heart events and she turns into a very good partner.
Infinite_Rough_7235 on
I vote for Hayley. Her character development is really good and she’s also my favorite aesthetically.
fir-baby on
This is my first ever playthrough and I chose Leah which I’ve been happy with! She is helpful on the farm and often makes me coffee haha. I’m not particularly drawn to Emily or Maru, but I might go for Haley or Abigail in a different save.
fir-baby on
This is my first ever playthrough and I chose Leah which I’ve been happy with! She is helpful on the farm and often makes me coffee haha. I’m not particularly drawn to Emily or Maru, but I might go for Haley or Abigail in a different save.
vincentninja68 on
Leah
She just knows how to live. Good food, adventurous, artsy and will literally fight for you if needed. Best girl.
15 Comments
I think people sleep on Penny honestly, she’s adorable, she’s kind, she’s a little nervous but that comes from living with Pam
I always choose Abigail because she is adventurous, likes video games and music, goth and has a guinea pig. But another good reason is so you can take her away from pierre because fuck pierre but the decision is 100% up to you I’m just saying my opinion
Which bachelorette did you pick ? And why is it Emily? (Or penny, *sigh* or Leah)
Honestly all of the “grown up” Bachelorettes are fine.
I usually find myself torn between Abagail and Haley , although in my latest game I’ve found myself really warming up to Penny.
All of them are quite good, having gone through all of them across many playthroughs my personal recommendations would be this:
1. Abigail, she’s got the goth asthetic and independence you have to admire.
2. Penny, honestly just rather wholesome and sweet. Also her bringing the kids to the farm for lessons after marriage just makes the place feel a lil more lively.
3. Maru, nerd girl who grows close to you because you let her nerd out.
4. Haley, annoying at first but is nice to watch her break out of her shell.
5. Emily, she’s quirky and fun. Mostly however I just personally enjoy being a menace to clint.
6. Leah, just because I have her last doesn’t mean her line still isn’t good. Becoming the inspiration for her art is charming, I just personally found hers the least interesting. You do get to punch someone in the face though which earns bonus points.
Of course my ultimate recommendation is to do multiple playthroughs and experience all the story lines. Each one is worth experiencing at least once. These are obviously based on personal tastes and everyone will have different preferences.
Abby. She’s not afraid to have and voice her opinion, she’s adventurous, she’s small and fierce, does not take crap from others… Oh, and she has some really funny lines, especially the one during Flower Dance. The fact I completely dig her aesthetics is just a bonus, really.
I love Haley and Penny. Haley because I love seeing the character development and Penny because she’s sweet and I want her away from Pam.
I chose Maru in my play through, but I haven’t played in a while and I’m pretty sure updates added stuff to marriage/ relationships (correct me if I’m wrong though). I chose her because I found her interests endearing and I just liked her personality overall. I think Leah is awesome too, I’ll probably romance her if I start another play through.
Maru. She is underrated, and really sweet. Love my nerdy wife. 
I’d go with Leah. She’s the closest you can to Robin without, you know… marrying Robin.
my first play I picked Maru and she was really great. She makes you food and gives you bombs. My second play I chose Abigail and she was great. I ended up buying her picture and hanging it on the wall. Now I’m married to Haley and I was very surprised at how sweet she ends up being. I kinda hate her room but I love her heart events and she turns into a very good partner.
I vote for Hayley. Her character development is really good and she’s also my favorite aesthetically.
This is my first ever playthrough and I chose Leah which I’ve been happy with! She is helpful on the farm and often makes me coffee haha. I’m not particularly drawn to Emily or Maru, but I might go for Haley or Abigail in a different save.
This is my first ever playthrough and I chose Leah which I’ve been happy with! She is helpful on the farm and often makes me coffee haha. I’m not particularly drawn to Emily or Maru, but I might go for Haley or Abigail in a different save.
Leah
She just knows how to live. Good food, adventurous, artsy and will literally fight for you if needed. Best girl.