"she goes from being in love with you, to just friends if you say you dont have the sale feelings for her" mate, I would be glad she just goes as only a friend rather than ghosting you, or even still going after you. Like, all in all, a not so bad, not so unrealistic response
DUDE THE only PERSON I HATE (except Clint obvi) IS PENNY LIKE SHE REALLY TRIES TO BE THE CLOSEST PERSON TO MY HUBBIE SAM WHEN SHE WAS LITERALLY AT THE CEREMONY
I don't have anything against Penny, but in her 8 heart event, you lose like 1500 points if you choose the "no I can't stand kids" option, which I feel is really out of bounds 💀
Nah, tbh, this was a bad take, at 10 hearts you are already dating right before marriage, makes sense she'd be rather upset if you suddenly went "oh yeah, nah I don't like you, lulz" And yes, even that 2 heart event, its bad, but it's obviously from naivete as opposed to malice
Regardless, she's a lot better than Haley at least
Penny and Sam clearly had a thing before the farmer arrived, and him lifting her into the tree coincides with her developing feelings for the farmer. Despite being close and wanting similar things Penny and Sam are just very different people. It's hard to imagine a future for the two of them that isn't 'sitcom wife x sitcom husband,' and neither would find that life fulfilling. For this reason I choose to interpret Penny's 8 heart event as her and Sam officially calling things off while choosing to remain friends
Okay. Saying this once again in yet another video that brings it up. To be able to see Penny's 10-heart event in the first place, you have to present her with a bouquet of flowers and tell her that you would like to pursue her romantically. She's not confessing to you. She's not trying to start a relationship. You already did that, and then you waited until she set up a romantic evening to reciprocate the feelings you already declared to get this far with her. At the moment she makes herself most vulnerable with you, that's when you chose to reveal that either you were lying to her the entire time, or you are somehow already over her, leaving her no idea what she did to mess up this relationship that you initiated . I think I can understand not wanting to talk to you for a while after that, and starting back at square one with her trust. Stop acting like you have to see every 10-heart event in-game, people. It's not required for 100% completion, and if you do it you're signing up to be a bit sleazy because you're either dating literally everyone available in town before ending up with your intended partner, or else you're two-timing said partner behind their back. It's not unreasonable that Penny breaks off her whole friendship with you if you play around with her like that; the unrealistic part is that no one else does
A lot of people dislike her because of her 2 heart event where she pushes George's wheelchair without his consent because she's trying to be "helpful".
I think it's fine that she loses friendship if you reject her after asking her out. But my ick with penny is that it feels like she's just trying to get with you as a way to get out of the living situation with her mom and not because she actually likes you. Half the time you talk to her she's complaining about her sad life and wishing she had a way out. I wish there was a way for you to help her move out as friends, I think after that the romance with her would feel sweeter as well.
Ok, I don't like Penny's whole tradwife disney princess in distress thing either, but to be fair to her, the 10 heart events only trigger once you're already dating. It's completely fair for her to be distraught if you tell her that you don't like her that way after you've given her a whole bouquet and everything
It's the same reason why I heavily disagree with people who are weirded out by Elliott's boat event. You're already dating by that point. It's not creepy to kiss the person who made a move on you and happily went with you on a boat date. Get over it.
Nah man penny is the best option for marriage! Most other bachelors/bachelorettes have hopes and dreams that they give up when they marry me (well except shane but he is problematic for different reasons). With penny you feel like you are giving her exactly what she always wanted and you not only save her from living in a trailer with her abusive alcoholic mom, you also prevent her marring a man child who will likely also make her do all the housework.
35 Comments
For anyone who DOES want to marry Penny:
She loves diamonds, poppies, melons, and emeralds, among other things.
Just be nice to her.
Trotsky reference ‼️⁉️
Meanwhile Penny is the only marriage option who doesn’t give up on her dreams after marriage. I think. Don’t quote me on that.😅
Lumni: talking about how she hates penny "Lumni can't help you."
the video: LUMNI LITERALLY MARRYING AND KISSING PENNY- 💀
I was gonna romance Penny on my first ever playthrough, but I answered all dialogs honestly with every character and she hates my opinions haha
Oh I guess my other comment violated community guidelines or something
"she goes from being in love with you, to just friends if you say you dont have the sale feelings for her" mate, I would be glad she just goes as only a friend rather than ghosting you, or even still going after you. Like, all in all, a not so bad, not so unrealistic response
DUDE THE only PERSON I HATE (except Clint obvi) IS PENNY LIKE SHE REALLY TRIES TO BE THE CLOSEST PERSON TO MY HUBBIE SAM WHEN SHE WAS LITERALLY AT THE CEREMONY
I don't have anything against Penny, but in her 8 heart event, you lose like 1500 points if you choose the "no I can't stand kids" option, which I feel is really out of bounds 💀
Walks children in nature. I recognize a hardcore Drag Race fan when I see one
she bursts into tears because in that scene you’re already dating her, so it’s basically saying “i never liked you even though i asked you out.”
As a person who married every single bachelorette at some point I’d rank penny top 3 AT LEAST
Nah, tbh, this was a bad take, at 10 hearts you are already dating right before marriage, makes sense she'd be rather upset if you suddenly went "oh yeah, nah I don't like you, lulz"
And yes, even that 2 heart event, its bad, but it's obviously from naivete as opposed to malice
Regardless, she's a lot better than Haley at least
And this is one of the videos where lummi didn't talk about haley
I don't like kids, but I always be friendly with all of the town. (Platonic relationship mod ftw!)
Well…I don’t care!
I love Penny as a character, but I genuinely forgot she is a bachelorette
i swearrrr ur rage baiting bro 😭 like no shit she'll get upset and cry if u tell her u don't feel the same way while dating her ?? LMAO
This entire video just further proves that you have horrible taste in partners
KEEP MY WIFES NAME OUT YOUR MOUTH!!
Penny and Sam clearly had a thing before the farmer arrived, and him lifting her into the tree coincides with her developing feelings for the farmer. Despite being close and wanting similar things Penny and Sam are just very different people. It's hard to imagine a future for the two of them that isn't 'sitcom wife x sitcom husband,' and neither would find that life fulfilling. For this reason I choose to interpret Penny's 8 heart event as her and Sam officially calling things off while choosing to remain friends
I marry, I have children, I divorce.
Okay. Saying this once again in yet another video that brings it up. To be able to see Penny's 10-heart event in the first place, you have to present her with a bouquet of flowers and tell her that you would like to pursue her romantically. She's not confessing to you. She's not trying to start a relationship. You already did that, and then you waited until she set up a romantic evening to reciprocate the feelings you already declared to get this far with her. At the moment she makes herself most vulnerable with you, that's when you chose to reveal that either you were lying to her the entire time, or you are somehow already over her, leaving her no idea what she did to mess up this relationship that you initiated . I think I can understand not wanting to talk to you for a while after that, and starting back at square one with her trust.
Stop acting like you have to see every 10-heart event in-game, people. It's not required for 100% completion, and if you do it you're signing up to be a bit sleazy because you're either dating literally everyone available in town before ending up with your intended partner, or else you're two-timing said partner behind their back. It's not unreasonable that Penny breaks off her whole friendship with you if you play around with her like that; the unrealistic part is that no one else does
When this cutscenes happened, Vincent asked if I had a boyfriend instead lmaoo
Lifted into a tree?!?!?! 😮
Lummi maybe the one with dark secret is actually you!
A lot of people dislike her because of her 2 heart event where she pushes George's wheelchair without his consent because she's trying to be "helpful".
I think it's fine that she loses friendship if you reject her after asking her out. But my ick with penny is that it feels like she's just trying to get with you as a way to get out of the living situation with her mom and not because she actually likes you. Half the time you talk to her she's complaining about her sad life and wishing she had a way out. I wish there was a way for you to help her move out as friends, I think after that the romance with her would feel sweeter as well.
……….men love librarians
Penny is the best❤
SHES AN AUTISTIC SWEETHEART AND ILL DO ANYTHING FOR HER
Ok, I don't like Penny's whole tradwife disney princess in distress thing either, but to be fair to her, the 10 heart events only trigger once you're already dating. It's completely fair for her to be distraught if you tell her that you don't like her that way after you've given her a whole bouquet and everything
It's the same reason why I heavily disagree with people who are weirded out by Elliott's boat event. You're already dating by that point. It's not creepy to kiss the person who made a move on you and happily went with you on a boat date. Get over it.
Penny be like: You called me a loser but I don’t see you walking children in nature
If yk yk
Nah man penny is the best option for marriage! Most other bachelors/bachelorettes have hopes and dreams that they give up when they marry me (well except shane but he is problematic for different reasons). With penny you feel like you are giving her exactly what she always wanted and you not only save her from living in a trailer with her abusive alcoholic mom, you also prevent her marring a man child who will likely also make her do all the housework.
Evil Lummi be like: Lummi don’t got you